Choose Between ASCAP and BMI
You can only be a member of one US PRO at a time. ASCAP is member-governed and non-profit — founded in 1914 and subject to a federal antitrust consent decree. BMI is free to join and recently transitioned to a for-profit model (2024).
If you are continuing this guide, you have chosen ASCAP. If you want BMI instead, use the BMI guide.
Key difference: ASCAP's "Follow the Dollar" royalty calculation system is highly transparent. BMI typically pays royalties approximately one month faster than ASCAP.
You cannot be a member of both — picking the wrong one and switching later requires resigning and re-registering all your works, which delays royalty payments by months.
Signing up for whichever you hear about first without comparing. Both pay comparably. The primary practical difference for independent artists is ASCAP's member-governed structure vs BMI's simpler open-door policy.